NOOOO! HOW CAN I CHOSE

yes. she can use her MAGIC

but garnet is also magic

Hm... I think it'd be an extremely close battle, but Star would win. Reason is, her magic completely out-ranges Garnet's Magic, which makes her fight more effectively. If Star did not have range, however, Garnet would win due to her massive strength.

true, but star wouldn't do anything deadly to garnet. she'll probably just use like jelly bean hallucination or that narwhal thing. Hey, if garnet can defeat onion, she can defeat star

ha ha… no Garnet is like a turret and compared to her, Star is just a sandcastle

I mean, Garnet can take a hit and punch back harder, Star most likely wouldn't take an attack from Garnet

maybe

I think Garnet would win. I mean Star has all kinds of magic but I don't think she's beat Garnet.