Collage by COLLAGE_SHOWDOWN

COLLAGE_SHOWDOWN


5 13
This round, we are eliminated FOUR people, so please list your 6️⃣ least favorite collages by username. Once again, we will list our top 3️⃣ favorites as well.
Remember, this round is supposed to be a collage style the contestant has not tried before, so if you don't mind taking a quick peek at their account to see if their entry was a different style before you list them as your least favorite/most favorite!
Ignore the entry from PositiveGemini, who is not a contestant in this challenge.
Please consider the entry with my username on it, it was submitted by r_rox who could not remix their entry to this collage, so I did it for them.
⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️
My least favorite (in no particular order) are: Seaflower99 (their collage had a style very similar to what they normal do, and the text was difficult to read), Kittycat2008 (text was just very sloppy, even considering it is a new style), Mayayouralive (looks like their normal style, there is too much going on and no main focus), Mountain-breeze (looks very sloppy, like it was not planned out well), Mon-amor (this collage creeped me out a bit and was simple, but not in a good way for me), and Breathin_dreams (the text clashed in a way that took away from the rest of the collage).
My favorites are r_rox, elf-king, and lucisious-mirimosa- who all did a great job of tackling a new style and their collages all looks beautiful!
My least favorites (in order from my least to most favorite): 1) seaflower99 (not different at all from their usual style, text is hard to read), 2) -Hunii- (very messy), 3) mayayouralive (simple, didn’t follow theme), 4) KittyCat2008 (messy), 5) mountain-breeze (very simple and the layout is strange), and 6) -light- (did not follow theme).
My favorites were elf-king, xxfloflox, and Lucisious-Mirimosa. I thought all 3 made collages that followed the theme of trying out new styles. elf-king’s text was stunning but different than their usual style. xxfloflox’s had a lot of really cool details, and although they’ve done a couple collages in this style since their entry, it was definitely a new style for them. luscious-mirimosa-‘s collage had a really cool aesthetic, and I liked that they went away from the heavy filters that usually detract from their collages.
also for the judge feature theme: maybe “make a collage inspired by your favorite book, movie, or tv show”?
my least favourites (from my last least favourite to my first least favourite): -light- (honestly I feel that it’s quite similar to what they do, like with the text, for me it’s to simply and definitely can be much improved), -Hunii- (too messy, can’t see the text at all), mountain-breeze (pngs are definitely randomly placed, the text is hard to read since they made it dark grey and the background is roughly the same colour if not black), mon-amour (really hard to read the text, doesn’t seem to be smtg new for them honestly, the background was horribly done), Breathin_Dreams (background is too messy, the text doesn’t match, more can be done to fix it but they did follow the theme)
my favourites in no particular order: xxfloflox (this is definitely smtg new she has tried and honestly I feel that she deserves the shoutout this round because she went around to comment on each of our page to clarify the misunderstandings that we might have if she had not told us the collage was actually smtg she tried before) and elf-king (super simple by beautifully done). I think @xxfloflox should deserve the shoutout this round since @elf-king got hers the last round, just to be fair yk. (sorry I only have two favourites)
extra notes: @livinghope-‘s entry isn’t actually smtg that she hasn’t tried before, I actually scrolled down her acc and saw that she has tried similar to her entry. i also believe that for the round, the contestants didn’t really put in their best into their work, because even tho the theme is smtg that they haven’t tried before, they should at least put in their best and try to “ace” the collage. i was hoping you could share this to the contestants to tell them to at least put more effort into their collages if possible.
for the theme: I actually did this sort of theme the last time I had a contest and I think there’s only one or two in this contest who was/were in the contest of mine. basically, I would think of an aesthetic and then use three emojis to describe it for example the theme is a vintage aesthetic, we can put 📀📻🛵 or if it’s a pink preppy aesthetic we can go with 👛🎀🌸. the contestants will then have to guess the aesthetic by themselves and give a reason how they got it, in order for us to see whether they cheated by copying. they would have to explain how they got the aesthetic thru the emoji combo like what emoji stand for what and overall how they got it. it’s just an example but I feel that it would be fun because this time, we can eliminate only those who did not get the aesthetic/theme right, instead of judging them based on their collage skills. if u wanna do this theme and need some help, do lmk :) and to prevent them from cheating, I think u could keep the aesthetic to yourself and when it comes to the judging, you can let me and @tr0vai11e then know.
I agree that xxfloflox should get this round since elf-king got the shoutout last time